Friday, November 9, 2001 Volume 67, Issue 57


Ex-Soviet officer gives advice on Afghanistan

By Ken Fountain
Daily Cougar Staff

The United States' best strategy in the military campaign in Afghanistan would be "to find and capture Osama bin Laden, declare victory and get out," a former Soviet military intelligence officer said Thursday in Houston.

Pin Lim/The Daily Cougar

Former Soviet military intelligence officer Victor Gobarev shows a Houston audience a USA Today story about Afghan history he said has several errors
during a Thursday speech.

Victor Gobarev was stationed in Afghanistan for four of the 10 years the Red Army unsuccessfully fought to vanquish the country's mujahadeen defenders.
Today he is an intelligence analyst for, an online "strategic forecasting" company.

He noted with some bemusement statements by Pentagon officials about the "surprising resistance" of the Taliban regime thus far in the U.S.-led military

"The Afghans are some of the toughest fighters in the world," Gobarev said. Unlike U.S. military personnel, who begin their training at age 17 at the earliest,
Afghans are trained in combat from the age of five, he said.

"What is special about Afghanistan? Everything," Gobarev said, from its "absolutely surrealistic landscape to its people, with their millennia-long history of
fighting against foreign invasion or influence."

Gobarev noted that Alexander the Great, regarded as the greatest military leader in Western history, "got bogged down in Afghanistan. (Afghans) are a
fiercely independent people."

He said the population of Afghanistan is actually a collection of vastly different ethnic groups, including the dominant Pushtun, the Tajik (who make up the
rebel Northern Alliance), and others, which are in an almost constant state of warfare. However, he said, if the country is invaded by a foreign force, such as
the Soviets in 1979, the various groups band together to drive the invaders out.

Gobarev said it was probably a mistake for President George W. Bush to launch the campaign. But, the deed being done, Gobarev attempted to describe
"what it takes to fight, not to mention win, the war."

The United States will have to accept the reality that it will have to maintain a ground troop presence in the country, but not the Army infantry, Gobarev said.

"I'm sorry, but our infantry are not ready for that kind of war," he said. He drew a comparison to the 1991 Desert Storm war, in which the U.S.-led coalition
fought an extremely demoralized Iraqi army. Often, Iraqi soldiers would simply throw up their hands in surrender at the sight of an American gunship

"This will never happen in Afghanistan," he said. The Afghans are expert guerilla fighters and marksmen, he said, and it would be disastrous to attempt a
conventional war there.

Instead, the United States should rely on its special forces troops, such as the Army Rangers or the Navy SEALs, and the Marine Corps to make
lighting-quick raids and rapidly get out.

At the same time, Gobarev said, the United States should endeavor to convince its allies among the nations bordering Afghanistan to take a more direct
role in the war. While nations such as Pakistan, Uzbekistan and Tajikistan are providing bases and other rear-guard support, they will have to send their
own troops into Afghanistan if the war is to be ultimately successful. He even made the surprising suggestion that Russia should be convinced to send its
troops into Afghanistan, from which the Red Army retreated ignominiously in 1989.

Gobarev's other startling suggestion was that Osama bin Laden was not the chief architect of the Sept. 11 attacks. While he is convinced that they were
planned by Muslim extremists, the true masterminds are only loosely connected to bin Laden and his al-Qaida network.

He said the likeliest culprits are radical organizations in Egypt or Saudi Arabia, government and wealthy elites he accused of using a "double-edged
strategy" of publicly supporting the United States while secretly funding the terrorist groups.

Send comments to

To contact the News Section Editor, click the e-mail link at the end of this article.

To contact other members of 
The Daily Cougar Online staff, 


Advertise in The Daily Cougar

Student Publications
University of Houston
151C Communication Bldg
Houston, Texas 77204-4015

©2005, Student Publications. All rights reserved.
Permissions/Web Use Policy


Last upFriday, November 9, 2001:

Visit The Daily Cougar